3. Women’s Colonial Lives
Life in Colonial America had many challenges. For women, the experience was both freeing in some respects – specifically, from patriarchal controls – but also horrifying. This era would witness women who were able to acquire wealth through marriage and entrepreneurship and women who would be tried and executed for witchcraft. Undoubtedly, women’s experiences were incredibly diverse.
How to cite this source?
Remedial Herstory Project Editors. "3. WOMEN'S COLONIAL LIFE" The Remedial Herstory Project. November 1, 2025. www.remedialherstory.com.
Join the Club
¡Únete a nuestra lista de correo electrónico y ayúdanos a hacer historia!
[object Object]
Life in Colonial America had many challenges. For women, the experience was both freeing in some respects – specifically, from patriarchal controls – but also horrifying. This era would witness women who were able to acquire wealth through marriage and entrepreneurship and women who would be tried and executed for witchcraft. Undoubtedly, women’s experiences were incredibly diverse.
Patriarchal (Adj.), relating to or characteristic of a system of society or government controlled by men. |
In a series of trials across colonial Massachusetts in the 1700s, women, often single or widowed, were charged with witchcraft. The historical causes of the trials are complex, but historians have noted a pattern: while any woman was vulnerable to accusation, most of the women accused of witchcraft had inherited property or wealth because they did not have husbands, sons, or brothers. Women who inherited economic power were prime targets of a society awash in religious extremism, fear of outsiders, and anxieties about social order and control. Between 1692 and 1693, more than 200 people, mostly women, were accused of practicing witchcraft. 30 were found guilty, 20 were executed– 14 of those victims of superstition were women.[1]
Worse, throughout the colonies, slavery was becoming synonymous with Blackness, and Black servitude was becoming a life sentence. Women in the Caribbean demonstrated their agency and lack of submission by leading slave rebellions.
Some women found opportunity in the religious movement of the period, known as the Great Awakening. For these women, this movement gave them more of a voice in churches and even resulted in some female preachers.
It was a time of tremendous change, colonial competition, solidifying footholds, and enduring restrictions on women’s rights and freedoms.
Salem Witch Trials
The Salem Witch Trials in 1692 marked a dark period in American history. Three young girls in Salem Village — Betty Parris, her cousin Abigail Williams, and their friend Ann Putnam, Jr. — displayed strange behaviors such as screaming, kicking, throwing objects, and contorting their bodies. A local doctor couldn't find a physical cause for their behavior and attributed the symptoms to witchcraft.
Witch trials and fear of witches had plagued Europe for over 200 years, mainly occurring between 1580 and 1650. Witch hunts took place in Germany, Switzerland, the Netherlands, France, and England, notably protestant Christian domains. Under Catholicism, when someone was accused of being a witch, the church would use the religious logic that God is all powerful and therefore this person could not be a witch. This theological reasoning prevented widespread witch hysteria.
One of the main causes of the witch hysteria was the decline in church power as a result of Protestantism, or the fracturing of the church by “protesters” against church corruption and policy led by Martin Luther and others. These trials typically targeted unmarried or widowed women and provided little opportunity for them to defend themselves, though any woman of any age or marital status could find herself accused. In the 1500s, several anti-witchcraft acts were passed by the English Parliament. And the 1640s and 1660s in England and Germany saw frequent trials for witchcraft. But by 1692, when the Salem trials occurred, witch hunts in Europe had begun to decline.[2]
Decades before Salem, Ann Hibbins of Boston was accused of being a witch. Hibbins had a history of speaking her mind and challenging her neighbors. In a long-running dispute with carpenters in Boston, she had accused them of overcharging for shoddy work. Church elders accused her of usurping her husband’s authority by publicly challenging the carpenters in church, and she was excommunicated. Her husband died 14 years later; soon thereafter, in 1654, she was accused of being a witch.[3]
Why Salem, Massachusetts became the center of witchcraft trials in the colonies is complicated. Long and violent wars with Native American nations and their French allies led to rising refugees from the frontier seeking help from established towns like Salem. Women who lived outside of traditional families, either as widows or as single daughters, did not sit well in patriarchal Puritan society. A strong belief in the reality of witchcraft and the power of the devil as a threat was part of everyday life in Puritan society. Collective economic stress, social stress, perhaps even mass hysteria, all may have played a role.
As for the three girls mentioned earlier, they had traumatic childhoods. In their short lives, they had already been separated from their families, worked as servants, and survived attacks by Native warriors. Betty and Abigail, living with troubled parents, engaged in a game of Venus Glass, a divination ritual, and sought help from an enslaved woman named Tituba when they became frightened by the imagery they saw. And while we know this was the spark, we have to piece together why the fire raged through Salem and took so many lives with it.
Games like Venus Glass lay alongside other folk magic rituals as a part of colonists' spiritual world. Charms to bring luck, to ward off evil, to heal, even to keep away witches were all practiced in colonial society. When the girls didn’t get better, their neighbor Mary Sibley instructed Tituba and John Indian, enslaved people in Betty Parris’s home, to make a “witch cake,” a charm made from urine and rye meal meant to harm the witch causing the illness. While colonists agreed that witchcraft was distinctly evil, there was no consensus about when folk customs became witchcraft.[4]
Reverend Samuel Parris, Betty's father, pressed for answers regarding her behavior. Under pressure, Betty and her friend accused Tituba, Sarah Good (a homeless beggar), and Sarah Osborne (an elderly woman) of witchcraft. These marginalized women were easy targets for the accusations. Sarah Good's four-year-old daughter, Dorothy, was also accused and imprisoned, enduring months of confinement, and eventually testifying under duress against her mother. While she survived physically, the experience left her mentally disturbed for life.[5]
Ann Putnam, Jr. and her family actively accused others. Ann Putnam's parents desired inheritances that were rerouted to their stepmother's children, fueling their bitterness. The Putnam family accused 46 different people, and Putnam’s testimony led to numerous deaths.[6] Her haunting nightmares of her deceased sister and other children contributed to her accusations against Tituba. These girls did not independently come up with their accusations. They were influenced by their parents and a legal system that took their claims seriously.
Under pressure and threats of torture, and despite being a devout Christian, Tituba confessed to witchcraft. Enslaved and lacking support, she likely felt she had no other choice. She accused the other two women as well. The two women denied the accusations but were found guilty and executed. Tituba, spared from execution, remained imprisoned for over a year before being released. She never regained her previous life and died in obscurity.[7]
While the poor and the young and those on the fringes of Puritan society were overrepresented among the accused, women from families of moderate wealth were overrepresented. Especially women who had some means by no husband or son to defend their property or their reputation. Indeed, historian Carol Karlsen has observed that inheritance disputes came up often in witchcraft trials. More alarmingly, women were accused of witchcraft soon after the death of their husbands, fathers, or brothers. These women, according to Karlsen, stood in the way of traditions that passed property from one generation of men to the next.[8]
As Karlsen’s research suggests, hysteria in Salem escalated in the 1690s, targeting wealthy and independent women. Martha Corey, convicted based on dubious witness testimonies, was accused of conversing with the devil and using witchcraft to harm others. Despite her denials, she was found guilty and sentenced to death.[9] Rebecca Nurse, an older woman, was dragged from her home and forced to confront her accusers. With no strong defense against their dramatic behavior, she said, "I cannot tell what to think" and cried out for divine help.[10] She was executed alongside four other women.
Increase Mather, the president of Harvard, warned against using "spectral evidence" in court.[11] This was a form of outdated legal evidence based on testimony by those who claim to have had visions from the divine. However, the Salem court ignored his plea. Denying that one was a witch seemed only to fuel the allegations and perceptions of guilt. Mary Easty, a wealthy woman who refused to join the witch hunt, was also convicted and hanged.[12]
Figure 3.1 This illustration, published in 1893, was titled “There is a flock of yellow birds around her head.” It depicts Mary Warren, who both accused her employer of witchcraft (she was a 20-year-old indentured servant) and was herself accused of witchcraft. While tried, she was released from prison in 1692. Much later, Warren’s story would inspire Arthur Miller’s 1953 play The Crucible (public domain).[13]
While women were the majority of those convicted, men were also accused, often due to rivalries or family disputes. Giles Corey, Martha Corey's husband, was pressed to death with stones for refusing to enter a plea.[14]
The legal process failed during the trials. The girls, primarily from the agrarian side of town, accused older and more powerful individuals from the wealthier side of town. Women constituted 14 out of the 20 convicted, mirroring previous European witch trials.[15] The trials were conducted entirely by male juries, and recent studies suggest that the gender composition of juries influences the outcomes.[16]
The trials ended in 1693 when public outcry led the governor of Massachusetts Bay Colony to dissolve the Court of Oyer and Terminer, which was responsible for the trials. Many convictions from the trials remain unresolved. The stories of the women involved serve as a reminder of the dangers of fear, superstition, and mass hysteria.
And this was only the beginning.
Life in the Colonies
Despite the grim end to the 1600s in New England, life in the wider American colonies during the 1700s stabilized and, in some ways, improved for white women. White women in the American colonies contributed to their household and community’s success and well-being through a wide range of responsibilities, like managing households with tasks like baking, sewing, educating children, producing soap and candles, as well as supporting or running family businesses such as farms or shops.
While women had more children compared to today, infant mortality was high, with one to three out of ten children dying before their fifth birthday. Giving birth was also dangerous, with a mortality rate of about one in 100 women.[17] The availability of skilled midwives and the wealth of the colony often impacted maternal and infant mortality rates.
As the colonies grew and diversified, social classes started to emerge. In the 1700s, women in the middle class often assisted their husbands in taverns, trades, or business ventures. However, despite their contributions, women had limited political and economic rights due to the concept of coverture. Coverture was a legal understanding that women were socially, civilly, and legally represented and, thus, protected, by their male heads of household. Under coverture, women were “covered,” and families' economic, social, and even political authority rested with fathers and husbands. Legal scholars of the time presented coverture as a special protection for women, a privileged place in the law in which women were favored because they were not responsible for the burdens of independent legal status. As William Blackstone, a professor of law writing in the 1800s, explained, “even the disabilities which the wife lies under are for the most part intended for her protection and benefit: so great a favourite is the female sex of the laws of England.”[18]
Coverture provided the legal rationale to deny women property and voting rights. Women did not have a separate legal identity, they were wives, daughters, even sisters. As legal scholars of the time explained, husband and wife were one person in law. Thus, women could not own property in their own name and certainly could not serve in political office or vote. Even though life expectancy was low, around 46-47 years old, becoming a widowed head of household did not grant women the right to vote. This idea of coverture would endure in American law long past the colonial period.
In the colonial era, women were active participants in various cottage industries, such as textile production, pottery, candle making, and soap making. They often worked from home, utilizing their skills and creativity to produce goods that were essential for local consumption and trade. The operation and management of a household depended heavily on women’s work, and her work in the dairy, garden, kitchen, or spinning wheel was just as essential to the family’s well-being as what her husband or father did in the fields or on a shipyard. At the close of the colonial period toward the end of the 18th century, small, home workshops became mechanized. Powered by water, these very early factories began to produce yarn, and by the early 19th century, whole cloth.
Much of this very early mechanized work was done by young women from nearby farms. They worked in these early factories, mills, and textile industries, operating machinery and performing tasks such as spinning, weaving, and, by the early decades of the 19th century, assembling products like shoes. Women's labor and expertise were pivotal in fueling these very early stages of factory production, shaping not only the economic landscape, but also paving the way for social and political advancements in the years to come. In fact, women and children were actually the most desirable workers in some of the first factories because they had fewer ties to the land and fewer obligations to agrarian farms. Plus, since women working out of the home – especially widows – were assumed to be in poverty and in economic desperation, they were a stable workforce whose labor could be purchased at a minimal cost. We will take up the story of these early factory workers in a later chapter when we focus on long and broad economic change that transformed a largely agricultural society into an industrial one.
Each colony had its own governing arrangements with appointed colonial governors and colonial assemblies making decisions about taxes. However, these assemblies began to be disbanded by the British Parliament during the build-up to the American Revolution, which the colonists saw as evidence of corruption. Women had little participation in these political processes.
The colonies had their own distinct characteristics. New England colonies were heavily Puritan and placed a greater emphasis on education. They specialized in shipbuilding and craftsmanship. Southern colonies focused on cash crops like cotton and tobacco, aiming to export wealth back to England, resulting in fewer investments in cities and schools. The middle colonies, recently acquired from the Dutch, welcomed people from diverse backgrounds and engaged in farming, fishing, and merchant activities.
For free and upper-class women, life was relatively better, and notable outliers like Susanna Wright emerged. Wright grew up in a Quaker family that emphasized equal education opportunities for girls. On the Pennsylvania frontier, she pursued intellectual and business interests, conducting botanical studies, writing essays, and serving as the chief clerk of the Wright's Ferry court. She advocated for the underprivileged in her community and cared for the sick, delving into medicinal herbs and medical science. Wright also campaigned for fair treatment of Native communities facing displacement by English settlers, establishing her reputation in the Wright's Ferry community.
With financial independence from her father's successful ferry business and inherited lands, Wright could pursue her scientific endeavors. She became the first person in Pennsylvania to successfully cultivate silkworms, exporting silk fibers to England for high-quality fabric production. Her achievements contributed to the development of silkworm farms and weaving factories among other colonies.[19]
Wright’s prominence connected her with influential figures of the time, including Benjamin Franklin, with whom she maintained a close friendship. She acknowledged her privilege, recognizing that many women in the colonies had limited opportunities, compelled to subordinate themselves to the wishes of their fathers and husbands due to prevailing laws, religious practices, and social customs.
Indentured Women
Many poor immigrants to the English colonies arrived as indentured servants and faced a challenging and difficult experience. Indentured servitude involved signing a contract, or "indenture," which obligated individuals to work for a specific period in exchange for passage to the colonies and possibly the opportunity to learn a trade. The colonies presented overlapping systems of “unfree” labor that affected people differently, and it mattered whether a laborer had arrived from Europe or from Africa and the Caribbean colonies. While both indentured servants and slaves were bound to their employers, there were significant and meaningful differences between the two legal statuses.
For European women from impoverished backgrounds or without family support, indentured servitude became a means of survival. Poverty, debt, or unfavorable circumstances in their home countries drove many women to become indentured servants. Elizabeth Ashbridge, for instance, was a young, poor, and widowed English Quaker who came to the Americas as an indentured servant after being disowned by her father. The woman who convinced her to travel back to Pennsylvania bound her before boarding the ship. Ashbridge worked diligently to quickly pay off her indenture. Over time, she found faith and wrote an autobiography about her life as an influential religious leader during the Revolutionary period.[20]
Terms of indenture varied, usually lasting from four to seven years. Throughout this period, servants worked for their masters without receiving wages. Their tasks ranged from household chores to fieldwork or skilled trades, depending on their abilities and the needs of their masters. This was also usually determined by the type of indenture that they had. Apprenticeships were the most favorable type of indenture, as the laborer would learn some type of handicraft, trade, or profession. These were typically male indenture agreements. Apprenticeships were rare, though, and most indenture agreements simply involved service. Indentured servants endured physically demanding labor, often working long hours with minimal rest or leisure time. Living conditions were basic and crowded, with servants sharing small quarters and lacking privacy.
Indentured servants were considered the property of their masters and could be bought, sold, or transferred without their consent. Physical abuse, sexual exploitation, and mistreatment were common occurrences that often went unpunished due to the servants' legal status. Pregnancy posed additional challenges as some women faced the prospect of raising a child while still in servitude. Despite the opportunity for a fresh start in the colonies, female servants from Europe found it difficult to improve their social standing or achieve economic independence. They encountered social stigma and had limited opportunities to acquire new skills or advance in society.
Upon completing their indentured servitude, female servants gained their freedom, but their prospects for a better life remained limited. Some indenture agreements had terms that provided for “freedom dues.” Freedom dues were farewell gifts of sorts. For apprentices, this might include the tools that would be necessary for the apprentice to establish their own business. Some indentured servant agreements indicated that the servant would receive a small parcel of land. These “freedom dues” varied from contract to contract – some agreements did not include “freedom dues,” but those that did were highly gendered. For men who were leaving their indenture to become self-sufficient heads of household, their “freedom dues” (often in the form of tools, materials, supplies, or land) would help establish them on their way to self-mastery.
For women who were not expected to own land, their freedom dues (if they received any) had to be small so that they could take them with them when they presumably married and moved onto the property that their husbands owned. We know, for example, of one indenture, Willy Honywell, who was to receive twenty-five acres of land and twelve bushels of corn once he completed his seven years of service. On the other hand, Alice Grinder, another indentured servant around the same time, only received two new outfits.[21] Some women, upon completion of their indenture, managed to establish their own households or find employment, while many struggled to secure stable jobs and faced ongoing difficulties.
While there were some similarities between the status of indentured servants and that of enslaved people, there were important, meaningful differences. Unlike enslaved people, indentured servants had contracts that eventually expired. Indentured servants had a bit of free will and could usually approve their indenture being sold or transferred to someone else. Importantly, unlike enslaved people, indentured servants had some legal right to challenge the conditions under which they worked. Altogether, these distinctions in their situation made indentured servitude different from the permanent and lifelong servitude endured by enslaved individuals.
Enslaved Women
Enslaved women and girls had no such privileges. From a young age, girls were assigned small tasks like picking up trash, tending to younger children, or scaring birds away from newly planted rice fields. As they reached adolescence, enslaved girls typically took on more regular labor. Older women who could no longer work in the fields were sometimes tasked with caring for enslaved children. The work patterns of enslaved women varied throughout their lives and according to the region they were in, as enslavers aimed to extract maximum profits from their labor. Apart from their physical and reproductive labor, enslaved women were subjected to the oppressive demands of fulfilling the sexual desires of slaveholders, overseers, and other men in positions of power.
In the decades that followed the first arrival of enslaved Africans in 1619, the British colonies transitioned from a workforce of mostly male, mostly white indentured servants to a slave society. Part of this transition would be accomplished through law. As we talked about in chapter 2, the colony of Virginia, quickly followed by other southern colonies, passed a law in 1662 that laid out the principle of partus sequitur ventrem, or “that which is born follows the womb.”[22]
In just about every other Western civilization, a person’s status was defined by their father. Your status as free, enslaved, aristocrat, wealthy, or poor was determined by your father’s status in life (and, potentially, whether he recognized you as his offspring). But this law indicates that a child’s status in Virginia would be based on the mother. The law stated:
Be it therefore enacted and declared…that all children borne in this country shall be held bond or free only according to the condition of the mother, And that if any christian shall committ fornication with a negro man or woman, hee or shee soe offending shall pay double the fines imposed by the former act.[23]
Why would a British colony basically turn its back on years of custom and common law? What effect did this law have? The answer is mostly practical. While paternity could be questioned, maternity could not. A child’s status in colonial society would be immediately apparent and unmistakable.
Importantly, this law suggests that colonial lawmakers felt some pressure to distinguish between these two types of unfree labor – servant and slave. The 1662 law is a turning point in the colonies. The decades before 1662 were a period in which the status of children born to enslaved women was a question, and eventual freedom for Africans brought to the colonies was not yet foreclosed. The 1662 Act hardened the distinction between servant and slave by insisting that the descendants of those enslaved had few opportunities to be free. The status of any child born would be based on the status – free or enslaved – of the mother, regardless of the father's legal standing. In other words, enslaved women gave birth to children who would inherit the status of slavery.
While colonial governments argued these laws were a way to settle questions about whether children should be free or enslaved, it also gave slave owners incentives to rape their enslaved women in order for them to produce more slaves. This cast a long shadow over the lives of enslaved women. While enslaved women’s experiences in slavery share many aspects in common with their male counterparts, the reality is also that, for enslaved women, fertility and reproduction added another dimension to their experiences that cannot wholly be understood by the rest of us. Enslaved women were workers, mothers, and survivors of sexual assault – enslaved women cannot provide true consent.
Figure 3.2 This 1853 painting by Eyre Crowe is titled “Slaves Waiting for Sale - Richmond, Virginia.” Crowe was an English artist and was horrified by the domestic slave trade. He wanted to shame those who enslaved others while emphasizing the humanity of black families. Notice his focus on black women as a way to represent the horrors of slavery. (public domain).[24]
White women upheld the system of slavery and benefited from it. While their responses to slavery varied, most were responsible for at least directing those assigned to work in the house, as well as managing clothing and food for the enslaved community. Young white girls often received enslaved people as gifts, even as infants. As when we talked about indentured servants and their freedom dues, gifts to these daughters of White slaveholders needed to be something that the women could take with them. It was not uncommon for women to receive enslaved people as wedding gifts, particularly with the expectation that they might serve as wet nurses when the bride became pregnant. Women also purchased them from slave markets. White women were a part of the culture of slavery.
It is important to remember that in the colonial period enslaved people labored in all 13 colonies – in the plantation fields of the South, on the docks and in the shipyards of the North, and in homes and small farms throughout the colonies. Manhattan had the second largest urban slave community in North America after Charleston.[25] In the period leading up to the Revolutionary War, slave holding would expand steadily in the southern colonies and decline in the northern colonies. In the colony of South Carolina, for example, the enslaved outnumbered the enslavers by 1708, and were two-thirds of the population by 1740.[26] Importantly, northern industries like shipbuilding, sail making, sawmills, and iron foundries continued to profit from slavery and were very much a part of the slave trade.
There are many reasons why American slavery developed where and how it did. Slavery was a more profitable system on the large rice and tobacco farms in the southern colonies than it was on smaller family farms in the northern colonies. For an expanded southern plantation elite, enslaved labor was cheaper than indentured labor. Indeed, enslaved women’s knowledge and skills in rice cultivation, a crop women had experience with from their homes in Africa, contributed to the success of this early cash crop.[27] Religious groups in northern colonies, like the Quakers in Pennsylvania, actively preached against slavery contributing to its steady decline. Finally, while southern colonies like Virginia introduced laws that distinguished slavery as an identity tied to race, by the 1770s northern states passed gradual emancipation laws, and many of these laws stipulated that the children of enslaved people were to be freed after a set period of indentured service.
Even as slaveholding and the slave trade itself expanded in the South, most enslaved people in the South were concentrated in the hands of a small share of slave owning men and women. And over time, wealth and slave ownership concentrated in an elite plantation class. In the colonial period, the vast majority of slave owners were of the small farm or middling sort. These slave owners often had fewer than ten enslaved people working on their farms. The elite among slave owners owned fifty enslaved people or more, as well as the best land and enough of it to make that investment in labor profitable. In most cases, small farmers owned fewer than five people.[28]
Figure 3.3 Here is an example of a Runaway Ad, in this case for a black woman named Ona (Oney) Judge. She was enslaved by George Washington (yes, that George Washington). While the new President’s family was in Philadelphia in 1796 (then the Capital of the United States), Judge ran before the Washingtons were able to send her back to Virginia, a slave state. Judge was pursued by the Washington family her entire life, though she was never captured (public domain).[29]
Like men, Southern slave owning women could be benevolent enslavers, or they could be incredibly cruel, and were just as likely to inflict violent punishments upon their enslaved. One woman starved her enslaved people and taunted them with candies. When one girl succumbed to her hunger, the enslaver rocked her rocking chair atop the girl's head while her daughter whipped her, permanently deforming her jaw. The inclusion of her white daughter as the whipper shows how the violence of slavery was something that was taught from generation to generation.[30]
Rebel Women
Enslaved people actively resisted slavery by rebelling, slowing down work, and running away. Enslaved women and girls sought freedom as soon as they arrived in the Americas, with some choosing collective escapes while others fled individually. The timing of their escapes varied; some women made their break for freedom immediately upon arrival, while others did so within weeks or even months later. An example is Juno, a 15-year-old girl who arrived on the slave ship Speaker in Charleston, South Carolina, on June 16, 1733. Just two weeks after being sold to a planter from Dorchester, Juno managed to escape.[31] These acts of self-emancipation by enslaved Black individuals show the consistency with which women resisted bondage.
Some responded with violence to the violence they endured under slavery. In 1708, an enslaved Indigenous man named Sam and a woman identified only as a "Negro Fiend" murdered their master and his pregnant wife, leading to their capture. Sam was hanged, and the woman was burned at the stake under an English law that punished her treason (her attack on her master was likened to a traitor's attack on a king). A few years later, a significant rebellion occurred in New York in 1712, involving enslaved Africans who killed nine white individuals and injured six others. The uprising resulted in the arrest of over 70 enslaved people, with 27 put on trial, including four women named Sarah, Abigail, Lily, and Amba. The historical record provides limited information, except to tell us that Sarah and Abigail, along with 19 others, were convicted and sentenced to death. However, one of the women was pregnant (the record is unclear if it was Sarah or Abigail), leading to a delayed hanging. Three years later, the governor would ask for a reprieve for the pregnant woman who had been held in jail all that time. We do not know what happened to her, whether she was ever released, whether she was eventually executed, and what happened to her child.[32]
Rebellions continued across the colonies, with the New York governor's house destroyed by a fire in 1741. Multiple fires occurred in subsequent days, leading to suspicions of another rebellion. A white indentured servant named Mary Burton claimed a conspiracy involving dozens of enslaved people attempting to overthrow the colonial government, causing panic among white individuals. Sarah, an enslaved woman, was accused by four people of deep involvement, resulting in her collapsing in fits and foaming at the mouth during court proceedings. Sarah faced intense interrogation, leading to the execution of alleged conspirators. As a consequence, she was sent to a sugar plantation in the Caribbean; essentially, a death sentence.[33]
Enslaved women laboring in the Caribbean also rebelled against plantation owners. While most of the histories of slave revolts focus on the role of enslaved men, enslaved women also fought for their freedom. Nanny Grig helped lead the 1816 rebellion in Barbados, coordinating information and telling enslaved people that the only way to achieve freedom was ‘to fight for it otherwise they would not get it.”[34]
While rebellions demonstrated the humanity and desire for autonomy and freedom among enslaved people, they also resulted in tighter control and scrutiny over the enslaved population. For example, a rebellion in South Carolina in 1739 led to laws requiring a 1:10 ratio between slave masters and enslaved people, as well as imposing prohibitions on enslaved people growing their own food, assembling in groups, earning money, and learning to read.[35]
First Great Awakening
Whether white, Black, free, indentured, or enslaved, religion and religious beliefs played an important role in the American colonies. The First Great Awakening in the 1730s and 1740s had a significant impact on women's subordinate status in the colonies. It was a period of intense religious enthusiasm that marked a significant shift in the religious landscape as many Americans renewed their commitment to God. The prevailing belief emphasized God's unlimited power and the necessity of fearing and following Him to attain salvation and avoid damnation. Notably, a large number of enslaved and Indigenous people converted to Christianity during this time.
Unlike a previous emphasis on formal theology, the focus during the Great Awakening shifted to cultivating personal experiences of salvation and fostering a heartfelt connection with God. This revival sparked the emergence of a new generation of ministers, including women. However, these religious women were still constrained by societal expectations and the view that women's involvement in public or mixed-gender settings was improper. Rev John Taylor noted that while Hannah Cave Graves was devout, she forgot her place in “her blunt dealings with preachers.”[36] Nonetheless, women found ways to participate.
For instance, Mary Reed had visions that she shared privately with her minister who then relayed them to the congregation while Reed remained calmly seated in the pews. Her humble demeanor bestowed authority upon her words among the worshipers.[37] Although women were not allowed to preach publicly in the church, a notable difference with Great Awakening preachers was that they took their message outside the church to the unconverted. In open-air settings, women's voices could be heard.
Martha Stearns Marshall was a renowned preacher who moved her congregation to tears. Described by her brother as a “lady of good sense, singular piety, and surprising education.” She and her husband underwent a conversion during the revival, leading them to live among the Mohawk Indians in an attempt to bring them to Christianity. When war broke out, they settled in Virginia, North Carolina, and later Georgia.[38] The Separate Baptist church Marshall belonged to differed from the "Regular" Baptists in that they granted women a more prominent role in worship and church leadership. Women served as deaconesses and eldresses and actively engaged in preaching.
Marshall was not the only influential female preacher. Bathsheba Kingsley, known as the "brawling woman," fearlessly embarked on a journey from town to town, spreading the message of faith and confronting townsfolk about their sinful ways.[39] Jemima Wilkinson transcended gender boundaries, identifying as neither male nor female, and delivered passionate sermons, evoking both fascination and disgust while adorned in a flowing robe.[40]
Some women struggled to navigate the complexities of spiritual equality and social inferiority. Margaret Meuse Clay, a pious woman, was asked to lead public prayers in her church, she was even invited by male ministers. However, her preaching was deemed excessive, leading to her and eleven male Baptists being sentenced to a public whipping for unlicensed preaching. She was spared when an unnamed man paid her fine. When Clay spoke about spiritual visitations, some male ministers mocked her and suggested these communications with God were only visits from a lover “in the Fire of Lust.”[41]
Women’s struggles to gain legitimacy and respect were compounded by factors such as race and class. Though evidence is fragmentary, it is believed that enslaved women may have served as evangelists on plantations. Stories passed down through later generations of enslaved people mention grandmothers and great-grandmothers exhorting in slave quarters.
Religion deeply influenced various aspects of women's lives, shaping their perspectives on suffering, marriage, motherhood, the body, and sexuality. For countless women, religion served as a guiding force, providing a sense of direction and allowing them to comprehend their position in the world. The societal changes brought about by the Great Awakening were remarkable, with traditional roles shifting as wives encouraged their husbands to pursue piety. Children became evangelists for their parents, and, in a bold move, some women spoke publicly about their faith.
Colonial Laws
Whether enslaved, Indigenous, or white, upper-class or lower-class, women suffered under a prejudiced legal system. Problems evident at Salem still existed by the end of the colonial period. Women took no part in designing laws and could be accused, arrested, tried, and executed by all-male rule makers and enforcers. In the colonial period, we can learn a lot about the lives of women through court records, although we have to take these sources with a grain of salt. They are not representative of the majority of women; instead, these are examples of the more extreme experiences women had. Furthermore, many of these sources were written by men about the women who were accused, and we rarely have sources provided by the women themselves. Based on verifiable sources, women were mostly executed on charges related to murder, attempted murder, or conspiracy to commit murder. Some were charged with witchcraft, and not just in Massachusetts. In fact, the first woman executed for witchcraft was in Virginia. Still, others were accused of arson, and one woman was executed for the crime of adultery.[42]
Aside from those criminal acts, having a child outside of wedlock carried significant social stigma in colonial America. For example, when Anne Orthwood became pregnant with twins out of wedlock in late 17th century Virginia, she became the subject of four different cases – civil and criminal – stemming from her indenture being affected by her pregnancy, demands for child support, and criminal fornication. Unfortunately, Orthwood died in childbirth. Her case was unique because the father of her child was related to a wealthy politician. Orthwood’s status as an indentured servant likely played a role in her lover’s decision to end the relationship and deny paternity.[43]
To cope with a rigid society in a time before effective contraceptives and sex education, abortion was common and legal up until the “quickening period.” Quickening was when the mother experienced fetal movement. Some women likely induced miscarriages because they feared social stigma, but that wasn’t always the case. Some women knew they could not provide for their babies emotionally, financially, or physically.
Some women were charged with infanticide. Infanticide is the act of killing an infant after it is born. While this crime is hard to imagine or understand, it’s important to refrain from looking at these issues through our modern lens and to attempt to humanize the subjects we study. In a time before formula or intravenous nutrition, and when infant mortality was high, a mother who couldn’t breastfeed, or a child who was ill or wouldn’t latch, did not allow for many options outside of a wet nurse. Animal milk is bad for infant digestive systems and wouldn’t have helped. If another lactating woman was not available, these poor mothers were often stuck in the impossible scenario of watching their baby starve or ending their suffering. It’s hard to imagine the pain of being charged with murdering your child, particularly when we consider the circumstances that led to it.
Women were heavily policed under English law in order to protect paternity, fatherhood, and property. At one point, concealing the birth of an illegitimate child was considered a capital offense. Concealment was punishable by death even if the baby did not survive. With no one to witness a “concealed” birth, there was no one to prove that the child had been born dead and – perhaps in a recognition of the social stigma of a child out of wedlock – the dead infant was considered a murder victim unless the mother could prove her innocence. Five women in colonial America were hanged for concealing pregnancies; three in New Hampshire alone. Again, the legal system failed women.
Ruth Blay was one of the women executed in New Hampshire for concealment. She was a poor school teacher who was likely impregnated by a prominent married man in her community. When she realized she was pregnant, she left her teaching post to live with distant relatives with whom there was a generations-old family feud that she hoped would not be used against her. When she went into labor, she delivered alone in a barn. The baby was stillborn and was soon discovered buried under the barn. Blay was inspected by local male physicians and accused of concealment.
She was dragged from her temporary home to a prison in Portsmouth. Her siblings came and testified on her behalf, but whatever they said in defense is lost. The entirely male jury found her guilty. The colonial governor gave her reprieves, but eventually she was hanged from a tree in December 1768.[44] Like the women accused of witchcraft in Salem before or the enslaved woman accused of treason for killing her enslaver, she was hanged by a legal system that gave women little choice.
Throughout, Blay maintained her innocence, that she had fallen and delivered at eight months. Rather than seeking forgiveness and mercy, Blay mounted a defense and insisted others conspired to find her guilty, “And though I die with a forgiving Spirit as to all my Enemies, but charge two women in particular to examine their own Hearts, as they will answer to it another day– whether they do not come under the Character of false witnesses?-- And whether Prejudice, Jealousy, or something else has not drove them thus to bear false Witness against me.”[45]
Conclusion
As the colonial era came to a close, women were divided by region, race, class, and loyalties. The slave trade was expanding, and the status of women in the colonies, both white and black, was increasingly restrictive and increasingly distinct. Women, who had been important economic contributors to the establishment and success of the English colonies, were now more likely to be referred to as emotional supporters of family life.
As we will see in the next chapter, the French and Indian War, an expensive and long war fought to establish English control over what was then the frontier of European settlement in America, would result in a series of taxes imposed on the colonists. These taxes directly hit every colonial home and would become a focus of colonial discontent. In this complicated conflict between European powers, various colonial settler communities, and Indigenous nations, enslaved and Indigenous peoples were left wondering which side would support their freedom and land claims.
By the end of this era, so much remained in question. What role would women play in the Revolution? How would class, race, and condition of servitude impact their loyalties? Would women’s status, rights, and laws improve as a result of the Revolution?
Checking For Understanding
What factors contributed to the accusations and convictions during the Salem Witch Trials, and why were women the primary targets?
How did the legal doctrine of coverture limit the rights and opportunities of women in the colonial period?
How did the law of partus sequitur ventrem affect enslaved women and their children?
In what ways did enslaved women resist slavery? Provide at least two examples from the chapter.
How did the First Great Awakening create new opportunities for women, even though traditional gender roles remained in place?
What do the cases of women such as Ruth Blay, Mary Dyer, and the women accused at Salem reveal about the colonial legal system and its treatment of women?
[1] Paul Boyer, and Stephen Nissenbaum. Salem-Village Witchcraft: A Documentary History. Boston: Northeastern University Press, 1972.
[2]Jone Johnson Lewis, “A Timeline of Witch Hunts in Europe,” ThoughtCo, February 20, 2020, https://www.thoughtco.com/european-witch-hunts-timeline-3530786.
[3] John Seven, “This Wealthy Woman Was Hanged as a Witch for Speaking Her Mind.” History, October 24, 2018. https://www.history.com/articles/witch-trial-execution-anne-hibbins-boston.
[4] Salem Witch Museum. “Salem Witch Trials Chronology & Timeline.” August 6, 2020. https://salemwitchmuseum.com/salem-witch-trials-chronology/.
[5] Salem Witch Museum, “The Untold Story of Dorothy Good, Salem’s Youngest Accused Witch,” 17 Jan 2024 https://salemwitchmuseum.com/2024/01/17/the-untold-story-of-dorothy-good-salems-youngest-accused-witch/
[6] Salem Witch Museum, “More About Thomas, Ann (Sr.), and Ann (Jr.) Putnam Home” https://salemwitchmuseum.com/locations/thomas-ann-sr-and-ann-jr-putnam-home-sites-of/
[7] “Life Story: Tituba.” New-York Historical Society, 2023.
https://wams.nyhistory.org/settler-colonialism-and-revolution/settler-colonialism/tituba/.
[8] Carol F Karlsen, The Devil in the Shape of a Woman: Witchcraft in Colonial New England (New York: WW Norton,1987).
[9]“Martha Corey Executed, September 22, 1692,” Salem Witch Trials: Documentary Archive and Transcription Project https://salem.lib.virginia.edu/n38.html
[10] “Rebeca Nurse Executed, July 19, 1692,” Salem Witch Trials: Documentary Archive and Transcription Project https://salem.lib.virginia.edu/n94.html
[11] Matthew Madden, “Increase Mather,” Salem Witch Trials: Documentary Archive and Transcription Project, https://salem.lib.virginia.edu/people/i_mather.html
[12] Douglas O. Linder, “Mary Easty,” Famous Trials, UMKC School of Law, https://famous-trials.com/salem/2040-sal-beas.
[13] The illustration is by Howard Pyle, published in Harper’s New Monthly Magazine, 1893 drawn from Rebecca Beatrice Brooks, “The Witchcraft Trial of Mary Warren,” History of Massachusetts Blog, August 13, 2013, https://historyofmassachusetts.org/mary-warren/#:~:text=Rebecca%20Beatrice%20Brooks%20August%2013,of%20thanks%20for%20this%20development. The illustration is available through Wikimedia Commons https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:FlockOfYellowBirds.png
[14] David C. Brown, “The Case of Giles Cory,” Essex Institute Historical Collection, vol. 121 (1985), 282-299.
[15] Alan Anderson, and Raymond Gordon. “Witchcraft and the Status of Women -- The Case of England.” The British Journal of Sociology 29, no. 2 (1978): 171–84. https://doi.org/10.2307/589887.
[16] Anderson, “Witchcraft and the Status of Women -- The Case of England.”
[17] National Geographic Education. “Women and Children in Colonial America.” National Geographic. May 20, 2022.
https://education.nationalgeographic.org/resource/women-and-children-colonial-america/.
[18] William Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England vol 1: pp 433. (1765-1769; reprint, Chicago, 1979).
[19]“Women & the American Story Editors, “Life Story: Susanna Wright,” New-York Historical Society, 2023, https://wams.nyhistory.org/life-story/susanna-wright/.
[20] Sonya Parrish. “Elizabeth Ashbridge (1713-1755).” Open Anthology of Earlier American Literature, Pressbooks, 2026. https://press.rebus.community/openamlit/chapter/elizabeth-ashbridge/.
[21] The Plymouth Colony Archive, “Servants and Masters in the Plymouth Colony.” 2026. http://www.histarch.illinois.edu/plymouth/galle1.html.
[22] Jennifer L Morgan, “Partus Sequitur Ventrem: Law, Race, and Reproduction in Colonial Slavery,” Small Axe: A Caribbean Journal of Criticism, vol. 22, no. 1, 1 Mar. 2018, 1–17, https://doi.org/10.1215/07990537-4378888.
[23] Laws of Virginia, Act XII, 1662 https://www.gilderlehrman.org/ap-african-american-studies/unit-2/origins-enslavement/laws-virginia-act-xii-1662
[24] Eyre Crowe, Slaves Waiting for Sale, Richmond, VA, 1861, illustration, Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Crowe-Slaves_Waiting_for_Sale_-_Richmond,_Virginia.jpg.
[25] Thomas J Davis, The Great Negro Plot of 1741, Hisotry Now, Issue 60 (Summer 2021) https://www.gilderlehrman.org/history-resources/essays/great-negro-plot-1741.
[26] “Slavery” South Carolina Encyclopedia https://www.scencyclopedia.org/sce/entries/slavery/.
[27] Judith Carney, Black Rice: The African Origins of Rice Cultivation in the Americas (Cambridge: Harvard University Press), 2001).
[28] “Freedom and Bondage in the Colonial Era,” Africans in the Americas, PBS https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part2/2narr1.html
[29] Frederick Kitt, Oney Judge Runaway Ad, 1796, image, Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Oney_Judge_Runaway_Ad_(cropped).jpg. For more on this interesting case, see the podcast Uncivil, https://podscan.fm/podcasts/uncivil/episodes/the-fugitive-1994.
[30] As quoted in an interview 2019 with Stephanie Jones-Rogers’s discussion of her book They Were Her Property: White Women as Slave Owners in the American South, (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2020), see https://news.berkeley.edu/2019/10/25/white-women-slaveholders-q-a/
[31]Karen Cook Bell. “Black Women’s Fugitivity in Colonial America.” African American Intellectual History Society. May 14, 2019.
https://www.aaihs.org/black-womens-fugitivity-in-colonial-america/.
[32] Rebecca Hall, Hugo Martínez, and Sarula Bao. Wake: The Hidden History of Women-Led Slave Revolts. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2021.
[33] “Life Story: Sarah.” New-York Historical Society, 2023.
https://wams.nyhistory.org/settler-colonialism-and-revolution/settler-colonialism/sarah/.
[34] Dawn Harris, “Nanny Grig,” Peoples of the Historical Slave Trade https://enslaved.org/fullStory/16-23-126829/ 31 May 2017
[35] A History of Racial Injustice Editors. “May 10, 1740 | South Carolina Passes Negro Act of 1740, Codifying White Supremacy.” Eji.Org, 2026. https://calendar.eji.org/racial-injustice/may/10.
[36] As quoted in Smith, The First Great Awakening, p. 285.
[37] John Howard Smith, The First Great Awakening: Redefining Religion in British America, 1725-1775 (Fairleigh Dickinson University Press), p. 154.
[38] Eileen Campbell-Reed. “Martha Stearns Marshall.” n.d. https://www.academia.edu/20316821/Martha_Stearns_Marshall?source=swp_share ; for quotation see Smith, The First Great Awakening, p. 285
[39] Smith, The First Great Awakening, pp. 157-9
[40] Serena Dresslar. “Who Was the Public Universal Friend? Living Outside the Gender Binary in Revolutionary Times.” 2023. https://www.nypl.org/blog/2023/02/16/who-was-public-universal-friend-living-outside-gender-binary-revolutionary-times.
[41] Smith, The First Great Awakening, p. 285-86.
[42] Demos, John Putnam. Entertaining Satan: Witchcraft and the Culture of Early New England. New York: Oxford University Press, 1978.
[43] John Ruston Pagan. Anne Orthwood's Bastard: Sex and Law in Early Virginia. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003.
[44] Carolyn Marvin. Hanging Ruth Blay: An Eighteenth-Century New Hampshire Tragedy. Charleston: The History Press, 2010.
[45] Michael Keenan Gutierrez, ”The Trial and Execution of Ruth Blay,” We’re History, June 12, 2015, https://werehistory.org/ruth-blay/.
Carolyn Marvin, Hanging Ruth Blay: An Eighteenth-Century New Hampshire Tragedy (The History Press, 2010).
Keep Going
I'm a paragraph. Click here to add your own text and edit me. It's easy.
Dirígete al siguiente capítulo para conocer más sobre su historia.







































