6. Women and the Trail of Tears
Indigenous women in the Southeastern and Northwestern frontiers of the United States found their communities in direct conflict with expansionist Americans eager to displace them. Whether White homesteaders seeking large plots of arable land or White Southerners who wanted to expand slave-based plantations, Indigenous communities were under significant geographic stress. Cherokee women in particular were affected by this conflict and endured despite the violent expansion efforts. Some White women used their positions to speak out against the atrocities, but more often than not, they were complicit.
How to cite this source?
Remedial Herstory Project Editors. "6. WOMEN AND THE TRAIL OF TEARS" The Remedial Herstory Project. November 1, 2025. www.remedialherstory.com.
Tritt dem Club bei
Melden Sie sich für unseren E-Mail-Verteiler an und helfen Sie uns, Frauengeschichte zu schreiben!
[object Object]
In the 1830s, Native Americans were forcibly removed from the Southeastern and Northwestern United States. The removals in the Southeast were deadly and became known as the Trail of Tears, but that term could be used to describe events in the Northwest as well. Centuries of Euro-American ideology had transformed the lives of Indigenous women, and the resulting social, cultural, and political changes challenged Indigenous definitions of womanhood. By the 1830s, Indigenous women had lost some, but not all, of the privileges and responsibilities they previously held. Men were negotiating with men, and women became witnesses to the horrors of removal. Women were responsible for keeping families together during this removal, in spite of the difficulties they faced.
The Trail of Tears was a shameful and horrific event. This chapter will include discussions of rape and sexual assault, as these are pervasive when violence is used against a civilian population.
Manifest Destiny
With the arrival of European settlers in North America, Indigenous communities saw aggressive encroachment on lands they used or inhabited. By the 1800s, the expansion of the United States was intentional, stated, and often in violation of prior agreements made with Indigenous communities.
Some politicians even made a career out of championing expansionism. Starting with President Thomas Jefferson’s purchase of the Louisiana Territory in 1803 through Andrew Jackson’s presidency in the 1830s, the US entered a period of gross and rapid westward movement.
Expansion was fueled by the ideology of “Manifest Destiny,” the idea that it was the United States’ destiny to expand and control the continent “from sea to shining sea.” This phrase, “from sea to shining sea,” suggests that expansion was both inevitable and welcome. It first appeared in Katharine Bates's 1895 poem, America the Beautiful. Bates, a professor at Wellesley College, was inspired by a trip with her family to Pike's Peak in Colorado in 1893. Pike's Peak, originally named Tavá Kaa-vi or Sun Mountain by the Ute nation, had been taken from indigenous control through a series of forced concessions in the 1860s.[1] Lewis and Clark’s exploration into the Pacific Northwest, beyond the Louisiana Purchase territory suggested this idea early on. And as early as 1828, maps of the United States show the nation stretching all the way to the Pacific.

This 1872 image, called American Progress by John Gast, was well known and was reprinted in a series of Western travel guides (public domain).[2]
The idea of Manifest Destiny was visually symbolized in an 1872 painting by John Gast, American Progress. American Progress is an idealized painting of Manifest Destiny with both racist and sexist portrayals. In the painting, Columbia, a female symbol representing the United States, sweeps across the western territories, bringing “civilization” to the “savages.” This piece of American propaganda covered up the wars, massacres, and land theft that occurred in the decades of rapid westward expansion. Instead, the image of an angelic-looking woman with a robe and a book takes up most of the frame. A closer examination of the painting, however, illustrates several themes. For one, the image is divided into two halves. Columbia herself is the divider. On the right of Columbia, we see all the markers of civilization and progress: canals, railroads, telegraph wires, and farming. On the left side of the image, we see all the markers of savagery and primitivism. The left side of the image is dark, but if you look closely, you see animals and Indigenous people seemingly running scared–and away–from Columbia.
In essence, this painting was designed to show man’s power over nature. Ironically, in this painting, the symbol for America was a woman, though women aren’t really prominent anywhere else in the image. A disproportionate number of the figures in the painting are male. The White men are all seen being productive on farms or operating the wagon trains moving west. White women are presumably passengers in the wagons, although their images are difficult to see. The clearest female figures are of Indigenous women, who are shown fleeing with the other native men, topless, or being dragged along.
Although not depicted in this image, debates over expansion were deeply tied to conversations about slavery, for as the US expanded, would those new territories be slave or free?
Manifest Destiny was not inevitable or benign, and it did not occur by some act of God. Rather, it was the result of White Americans' desires for valuable land, government policies that supported White encroachment, and broadly held racist beliefs that Native communities would and should give way. Male leaders in the United States, perhaps spurred on by fearful wives, took direct action to remove and massacre the Indigenous communities that stood in the way of White, settler migrations. The foremost of these men was Andrew Jackson.

This 1847 image of the Battle at Horseshoe Bend presents the conflict from the perspective of the American soldiers (public domain).[3]
Andrew Jackson and the Cherokee
Growing up, Jackson listened to stories of native violence toward settlers and developed prejudices, like many Americans. He called Indigenous people “savages” and believed they should be removed to make room for White settlers. Jackson earned a name for himself after his heroics in the War of 1812 and would go on to found the longest lasting political party in US history, the Democratic Party. However, it would be his treatment of the Cherokee that he would be most remembered for.
In 1814, Jackson tried to wipe out the Red Sticks community in modern Alabama (ironically a Native American word meaning “Great Lands”) in a full on assault. Illustrative of the complicated alliances formed between White and Indigenous communities, he only won this conflict because the Cherokee Nation reinforced him. The Red Sticks lost almost 900 warriors. Junaluska, a Cherokee man, saved Jackson from death. Almost immediately, their support was forgotten. Jackson confiscated 23 million acres of land in Alabama and Georgia—some of which belonged to the Cherokee.
The Cherokee and other major tribes of the Southeast lived on fertile land that White settlers wanted to exploit for the production of cotton on large plantations. Instead of signing bad treaties with the US and moving west like other tribes, the Cherokee converted to Christianity, developed a written language, printed a newspaper, and sent children to schools for formal education, in what historians call the Cherokee Renaissance.[4]
The Cherokee’s relationship with slavery was complicated. They both enslaved people but also harbored and protected those who ran away from slavery. The Cherokee had practiced slavery before the arrival of Europeans, and those they enslaved were often captured from other tribes during conflicts. Slavery for the Cherokee traditionally was a way of expanding their tribe, and captured enslaved people were incorporated into village life to replace those lost to war.
With the arrival of Europeans and the African slave trade they engineered, Cherokee slave holding was increasingly motivated by the value of people as property rather than as future members of the community. By the late 1700s, the Cherokee, like their southern White neighbors, had a plantation economy worked by enslaved Africans. Over time, the Cherokee developed laws to prohibit intermarriage between Cherokee and enslaved people, forbid teaching enslaved people to read and write, and even laws dictating punishments for runaways. Some Cherokees suggested that slaveholding was evidence of their equality with White Americans.[5]
Like many Indigenous cultures, Cherokee women living in the early 1800s held significant positions in their communities, even after centuries of contact with patriarchal Europeans. Despite women sitting at the helm of communities like the Cherokee, White men, like Jackson, preferred to deal with Native men in trade and political negotiations.
Role of Cherokee Women
Many White settlers did not comprehend the Cherokee notion of female equality. Women were valued and respected in ways White settlers found strange. Families were matrilineal, meaning that family lineage was traced through mothers rather than fathers, and mothers were the guardians of their children. For a Cherokee child, their mother’s brother was the most important male figure in the family. Fathers were not formally related to, nor had a formal relationship with, their children. Compare this to European legal traditions that gave all parental rights to fathers. Women could own property and participate in the tribe’s governing councils. Cherokee women were sexually liberated, entering unions by choice and exiting them when they wanted. Sexual relations between consenting adults were always considered natural or spiritual. They did not have the same notions of shame and sin that European or White American women had.
Cherokee women were sometimes sought as marriage partners by White men because they controlled the family wealth and belongings. By marrying Cherokee women, White men could gain access to Cherokee wealth and property. However, White men were shocked to learn that their wives controlled the children and made decisions about property. The Cherokee passed laws that penalized men who abandoned their wives, revoking their citizenship and forcing them to pay fines.[6]
Men and women performed different types of work–men hunted and women gathered food and farmed the land–but for Cherokee women, motherhood was a source of power, not oppression. Cherokee women were equals of men and held in high regard. Cherokee “War Women” even fought in battles alongside men.[7]
Every fall, the Cherokee people held a festival to honor Selu, the Corn Mother, who sacrificed her life so that her sons and the entire Cherokee people could live. Cherokee communities continue to hold the Green Corn Ceremony, known in Cherokee as Itse Selu. The festival celebrated the bounty of the harvest and the power of the woman who had saved her people.[8]
But by the 1800s, things were beginning to change for the Cherokee. Jefferson purchased the Louisiana Territory and committed the federal government to future removal of the Creek and the Cherokee from Georgia.
Not all Americans endorsed Native removal and instead pushed for civilization and assimilation. For Cherokee men and women, becoming “civilized” meant a complete reversal of centuries old gender norms and major changes in attitudes towards sexuality and the body. The government and missionaries introduced Euro-American and Christian values of “true womanhood” and confined the strong Cherokee women to the domestic sphere. Over time, marriages and integration between Cherokee and White culture furthered this shift.
The Cherokee began to feel pressure from all sides and saw accepting, even begrudgingly, White norms as a path to maintaining their traditional homelands. Many embraced Euro-American dress and religion, art, and culture, though some did not, especially those who lived in the western Appalachian Mountains and experienced less settler contact. Women ceased farming as that was now men’s work. Women began to lose their sense of what womanhood was as there seemed to be no clear definition. Buck Watie, a member of a prominent Cherokee family and a convert to Christianity who worked as a missionary among the Cherokee, wrote, “A wife! What a sacred name, what a responsible office!... She must be an unspotted sanctuary to which wearied men flow from the crimes of the world, and feel that no sin dare enter there. A wife! She must be the guardian angel of his footsteps on earth, and guide him to Heaven.”[9] His depiction offered little of the political and social power Cherokee women had held in their communities.
Indeed, this definition of a wife was far removed from the ways of the traditional Cherokee matriarchs. Men’s roles may have felt even more changed than women's
