top of page

6. Women and the Trail of Tears

Indigenous women in the Southeastern and Northwestern frontiers of the United States found their communities in direct conflict with expansionist Americans eager to displace them. Whether White homesteaders seeking large plots of arable land or White Southerners who wanted to expand slave-based plantations, Indigenous communities were under significant geographic stress. Cherokee women in particular were affected by this conflict and endured despite the violent expansion efforts. Some White women used their positions to speak out against the atrocities, but more often than not, they were complicit.

How to cite this source?

 

Remedial Herstory Project Editors. "6. WOMEN AND THE TRAIL OF TEARS" The Remedial Herstory Project. November 1, 2025. www.remedialherstory.com.

Tritt dem Club bei

Melden Sie sich für unseren E-Mail-Verteiler an und helfen Sie uns, Frauengeschichte zu schreiben!

Thanks for submitting!

[object Object]

​

​

In the 1830s, Native Americans were forcibly removed from the Southeastern and Northwestern United States. The removals in the Southeast were deadly and became known as the Trail of Tears, but that term could be used to describe events in the Northwest as well. Centuries of Euro-American ideology had transformed the lives of Indigenous women, and the resulting social, cultural, and political changes challenged Indigenous definitions of womanhood. By the 1830s, Indigenous women had lost some, but not all, of the privileges and responsibilities they previously held. Men were negotiating with men, and women became witnesses to the horrors of removal. Women were responsible for keeping families together during this removal, in spite of the difficulties they faced.

The Trail of Tears was a shameful and horrific event. This chapter will include discussions of rape and sexual assault, as these are pervasive when violence is used against a civilian population.


Manifest Destiny

With the arrival of European settlers in North America, Indigenous communities saw aggressive encroachment on lands they used or inhabited. By the 1800s, the expansion of the United States was intentional, stated, and often in violation of prior agreements made with Indigenous communities.

Some politicians even made a career out of championing expansionism. Starting with President Thomas Jefferson’s purchase of the Louisiana Territory in 1803 through Andrew Jackson’s presidency in the 1830s, the US entered a period of gross and rapid westward movement.

Expansion was fueled by the ideology of “Manifest Destiny,” the idea that it was the United States’ destiny to expand and control the continent “from sea to shining sea.” This phrase, “from sea to shining sea,” suggests that expansion was both inevitable and welcome. It first appeared in Katharine Bates's 1895 poem, America the Beautiful. Bates, a professor at Wellesley College, was inspired by a trip with her family to Pike's Peak in Colorado in 1893. Pike's Peak, originally named Tavá Kaa-vi or Sun Mountain by the Ute nation, had been taken from indigenous control through a series of forced concessions in the 1860s.[1] Lewis and Clark’s exploration into the Pacific Northwest, beyond the Louisiana Purchase territory suggested this idea early on. And as early as 1828, maps of the United States show the nation stretching all the way to the Pacific.

 

This 1872 image, called American Progress by John Gast, was well known and was reprinted in a series of Western travel guides (public domain).[2]

 

The idea of Manifest Destiny was visually symbolized in an 1872  painting by John Gast, American Progress. American Progress is an idealized painting of Manifest Destiny with both racist and sexist portrayals. In the painting, Columbia, a female symbol representing the United States, sweeps across the western territories, bringing “civilization” to the “savages.” This piece of American propaganda covered up the wars, massacres, and land theft that occurred in the decades of rapid westward expansion. Instead, the image of an angelic-looking woman with a robe and a book takes up most of the frame. A closer examination of the painting, however, illustrates several themes. For one, the image is divided into two halves. Columbia herself is the divider. On the right of Columbia, we see all the markers of civilization and progress: canals, railroads, telegraph wires, and farming. On the left side of the image, we see all the markers of savagery and primitivism. The left side of the image is dark, but if you look closely, you see animals and Indigenous people seemingly running scared–and away–from Columbia.

In essence, this painting was designed to show man’s power over nature. Ironically, in this painting, the symbol for America was a woman, though women aren’t really prominent anywhere else in the image. A disproportionate number of the figures in the painting are male. The White men are all seen being productive on farms or operating the wagon trains moving west. White women are presumably passengers in the wagons, although their images are difficult to see. The clearest female figures are of Indigenous women, who are shown fleeing with the other native men, topless, or being dragged along.

Although not depicted in this image, debates over expansion were deeply tied to conversations about slavery, for as the US expanded, would those new territories be slave or free?

Manifest Destiny was not inevitable or benign, and it did not occur by some act of God. Rather, it was the result of White Americans' desires for valuable land, government policies that supported White encroachment, and broadly held racist beliefs that Native communities would and should give way. Male leaders in the United States, perhaps spurred on by fearful wives, took direct action to remove and massacre the Indigenous communities that stood in the way of White, settler migrations. The foremost of these men was Andrew Jackson.


This 1847 image of the Battle at Horseshoe Bend presents the conflict from the perspective of the American soldiers (public domain).[3]


Andrew Jackson and the Cherokee

Growing up, Jackson listened to stories of native violence toward settlers and developed prejudices, like many Americans. He called Indigenous people “savages” and believed they should be removed to make room for White settlers. Jackson earned a name for himself after his heroics in the War of 1812 and would go on to found the longest lasting political party in US history, the Democratic Party. However, it would be his treatment of the Cherokee that he would be most remembered for.

In 1814, Jackson tried to wipe out the Red Sticks community in modern Alabama (ironically a Native American word meaning “Great Lands”) in a full on assault. Illustrative of the complicated alliances formed between White and Indigenous communities, he only won this conflict because the Cherokee Nation reinforced him. The Red Sticks lost almost 900 warriors. Junaluska, a Cherokee man, saved Jackson from death. Almost immediately, their support was forgotten. Jackson confiscated 23 million acres of land in Alabama and Georgia—some of which belonged to the Cherokee.

The Cherokee and other major tribes of the Southeast lived on fertile land that White settlers wanted to exploit for the production of cotton on large plantations. Instead of signing bad treaties with the US and moving west like other tribes, the Cherokee converted to Christianity, developed a written language, printed a newspaper, and sent children to schools for formal education, in what historians call the Cherokee Renaissance.[4]

The Cherokee’s relationship with slavery was complicated. They both enslaved people but also harbored and protected those who ran away from slavery. The Cherokee had practiced slavery before the arrival of Europeans, and those they enslaved were often captured from other tribes during conflicts. Slavery for the Cherokee traditionally was a way of expanding their tribe, and captured enslaved people were incorporated into village life to replace those lost to war.

With the arrival of Europeans and the African slave trade they engineered, Cherokee slave holding was increasingly motivated by the value of people as property rather than as future members of the community. By the late 1700s, the Cherokee, like their southern White neighbors, had a plantation economy worked by enslaved Africans. Over time, the Cherokee developed laws to prohibit intermarriage between Cherokee and enslaved people, forbid teaching enslaved people to read and write, and even laws dictating punishments for runaways. Some Cherokees suggested that slaveholding was evidence of their equality with White Americans.[5]

Like many Indigenous cultures, Cherokee women living in the early 1800s held significant positions in their communities, even after centuries of contact with patriarchal Europeans. Despite women sitting at the helm of communities like the Cherokee, White men, like Jackson, preferred to deal with Native men in trade and political negotiations.

 

Role of Cherokee Women

Many White settlers did not comprehend the Cherokee notion of female equality. Women were valued and respected in ways White settlers found strange. Families were matrilineal, meaning that family lineage was traced through mothers rather than fathers, and mothers were the guardians of their children. For a Cherokee child, their mother’s brother was the most important male figure in the family. Fathers were not formally related to, nor had a formal relationship with, their children. Compare this to European legal traditions that gave all parental rights to fathers. Women could own property and participate in the tribe’s governing councils. Cherokee women were sexually liberated, entering unions by choice and exiting them when they wanted. Sexual relations between consenting adults were always considered natural or spiritual. They did not have the same notions of shame and sin that European or White American women had.

Cherokee women were sometimes sought as marriage partners by White men because they controlled the family wealth and belongings. By marrying Cherokee women, White men could gain access to Cherokee wealth and property. However, White men were shocked to learn that their wives controlled the children and made decisions about property. The Cherokee passed laws that penalized men who abandoned their wives, revoking their citizenship and forcing them to pay fines.[6]

Men and women performed different types of work–men hunted and women gathered food and farmed the land–but for Cherokee women, motherhood was a source of power, not oppression. Cherokee women were equals of men and held in high regard. Cherokee “War Women” even fought in battles alongside men.[7]

Every fall, the Cherokee people held a festival to honor Selu, the Corn Mother, who sacrificed her life so that her sons and the entire Cherokee people could live. Cherokee communities continue to hold the Green Corn Ceremony, known in Cherokee as Itse Selu. The festival celebrated the bounty of the harvest and the power of the woman who had saved her people.[8]

But by the 1800s, things were beginning to change for the Cherokee. Jefferson purchased the Louisiana Territory and committed the federal government to future removal of the Creek and the Cherokee from Georgia.

Not all Americans endorsed Native removal and instead pushed for civilization and assimilation.  For Cherokee men and women, becoming “civilized” meant a complete reversal of centuries old gender norms and major changes in attitudes towards sexuality and the body. The government and missionaries introduced Euro-American and Christian values of “true womanhood” and confined the strong Cherokee women to the domestic sphere. Over time, marriages and integration between Cherokee and White culture furthered this shift.

The Cherokee began to feel pressure from all sides and saw accepting, even begrudgingly, White norms as a path to maintaining their traditional homelands. Many embraced Euro-American dress and religion, art, and culture, though some did not, especially those who lived in the western Appalachian Mountains and experienced less settler contact. Women ceased farming as that was now men’s work. Women began to lose their sense of what womanhood was as there seemed to be no clear definition. Buck Watie, a member of a prominent Cherokee family and a convert to Christianity who worked as a missionary among the Cherokee, wrote, “A wife! What a sacred name, what a responsible office!... She must be an unspotted sanctuary to which wearied men flow from the crimes of the world, and feel that no sin dare enter there. A wife! She must be the guardian angel of his footsteps on earth, and guide him to Heaven.”[9] His depiction offered little of the political and social power Cherokee women had held in their communities.

Indeed, this definition of a wife was far removed from the ways of the traditional Cherokee matriarchs. Men’s roles may have felt even more changed than women's because they no longer hunted and fought as warriors for the community. Instead, they were tied to the land, doing what traditional Cherokee saw as “women’s work.” This would have been a big challenge to their masculinity. Like owning enslaved people, changes in Cherokee domestic relationships were often pointed to as evidence of how “civilized” the tribe had become.

Tensions continued to mount. In 1816, the Cherokee sent two young men, John Ross and Major Ridge, to Washington to negotiate with the US government over land that had been taken. Important to note that John Ross was a major slaveholder among the Cherokee. Ross and Ridge negotiated a deal that would have sold Cherokee land in South Carolina to the United States. Not everyone thought compromise was the path forward. Nanyehi (“She who walks among the spirits”) had lived through the American Revolution and had always been a champion of cooperation between settlers and Natives. Nanyehi, a Beloved Woman of the Cherokee Nation and once a leader of the Nation, was now 80-years old and living in a community under threat. The time for cooperation, according to Nanyehi, was over. She sent her son to read a plea signed by twelve women on the Women’s Council, including her daughter and granddaughter: “Our beloved children and head men of the Cherokee Nation, we address you warriors in council. We have raised all of you on the land which we now have. . . . We know that our country has once been extensive, but by repeated sales has become circumscribed to a small tract. . . . Your mothers, your sisters ask and beg of you not to part with any more of our land.” The Council passed a resolution vowing not to give another acre to the United States.[10] 

A year later, Jackson, as a Federal Indian Commissioned Officer, worked to expel the Cherokee from Tennessee. He used bribes and threats and was successful in getting many to leave. By 1822, Ross and 16,000 Cherokees remained resolved to hold the line.

The Cherokee continued to morph their society to be more Euro-American and maintain their autonomy. In 1827, they adopted a new constitution that included an executive, legislative, and judicial branch. The constitution stripped Cherokee women of political involvement. They became disenfranchised and were unable to serve on the Council. Nanyehi’s daughters and granddaughters would have much different lives and roles than she did. Moreover, like the southern plantation society around them, the Cherokee did not abolish slavery until 1863 and did not grant citizenship rights to the formerly enslaved until 1866.

 

Rachel Jackson

Despite, or perhaps because of, his history as an “Indian Remover,” Jackson eventually won the presidency: an endorsement by the voting American people (White men) of his policies. But Jackson’s path to the Presidency was mired in controversy. He lost the presidential election in 1824 in a bitter battle with John Quincy Adams. The 1828 rematch cost Jackson dearly. Up for reelection, Adams’s supporters sought to defeat him again and this time they focused the public’s attention on Jackson’s wife– Rachel.

 

Painted here between 1830 and 1832, Rachel Jackson died just days after her husband’s election and never served as first lady. Her niece took on that role after her death (public domain).[11]


 

Adams’s supporters argued that Jackson was unfit to be president because of the circumstances surrounding his marriage. Although the Jacksons had been married for nearly 40 years by the time of this election, those years were all negated by the troubled beginning of their marriage. Rachel Jackson was a “divorcee.” And worse, evidence came into Adams’s hands that her divorce from her first husband was never finalized because her first husband never completed the paperwork. Her first marriage was an unhappy one. At this time, divorce was difficult, and couples had to petition their state legislatures. Between 1786 and 1827, Virginia granted only 42 bills of divorce; one went to Jackson’s husband in 1790. After getting a bill from the legislature, couples then needed to take their case to court, a step Jackson’s first husband never did. Rachel Jackson wanted to provoke her husband to finalize the divorce by marrying Andrew Jackson, a man she was in love with. As historian Ann Toplovich explains, “that a woman of Rachel [Jackson’s] status chose the extralegal recourse of desertion to end her marriage is extraordinary. Elite women were expected to tolerate outrageous behavior on the part of their husbands.” Rachel Jackson took control over her life despite the social consequences she no doubt knew she would face.[12]

The Adams campaign dug into this scandal and attacked Rachel Jackson’s morals. They called her a whore and branded her the “profligate woman” – by which they meant that she was shamelessly immoral.  The Jacksons fought back by publishing a pamphlet, renewing their vows, and casting Jackson as a defender of women. He ultimately won the election, but Rachel Jackson was devastated by the vile attacks on her character, and they quickly took their toll. While her health had been poor for some years, she deteriorated during the campaign and died of a heart attack in 1828. Her tombstone would read, “A being so gentle and so virtuous, slander might wound but could not dishonor.”[13] 

Rachel Jackson was buried in the dress she had planned to wear to her husband’s inaugural ball. Her story reveals the significant constraints women, even White women of high social status, had to negotiate. Legal inequality and social stigma were powerful tools that limited the decisions women could make in their personal lives. Like Jackson, Peggy Eaton would also find herself caught intersecting networks of political power, social hierarchy, and gendered constraints.

 

Peggy Eaton

After the cruel attacks and death of his wife, Andrew Jackson was a bitter man when he entered the White House as the first Democratic president. His administration was soon mired in a second political scandal with another White woman: Margaret “Peggy” Eaton. Eaton had recently married Jackson’s Secretary of War, John Eaton, after Peggy Eaton’s first husband died at sea. But rumors soon surfaced that Peggy and John had been having an affair while she was married. Because of these rumors, many of the elite women in Washington, D.C. refused to socialize with her.

Floride Calhoun, the wife of the Vice President, was the ringleader of the society ladies and would not attend events if Peggy Eaton was there. Because Peggy Eaton’s father owned a tavern, rumors also swirled that she had been sexually promiscuous and perhaps even a sex worker. Since a woman’s social status was tied to her perceived virtue, these women feared Peggy Eaton’s potential promiscuity would malign them by proxy.

Jackson took the Eatons’s side during this scandal, which was referred to as the “Petticoat Affair,” and privately and publicly defended the couple. Ultimately, the affair was resolved by Jackson dismissing members of his cabinet and sending them out of Washington to other political appointments. When asked about the scandal, Jackson remarked, “I would rather have live vermin on my back than the tongue of one of these Washington women on my reputation.”[14] It’s clear from the Eaton Affair that women in Washington held political sway–even the power to change a presidential cabinet. Jackson had defended both Rachel Jackson and Peggy Eaton, but what about women of color? Did his policies toward the Native Americans and the enslaved offer these women opportunities for self-determination? In short, they did not.

 

Indian Removal Act

Removal of Native Americans from the Southeast was one of Jackson’s top priorities in office. In 1830, Jackson signed the Indian Removal Act into law, giving the federal government the power to exchange Native-held land in the cotton growing region east of the Mississippi for land to the west, in “Indian Territory” located in present-day Oklahoma. This exchange would also result in the forced removal of Indigenous people from their ancient ancestral homelands in the southeast and the cotton territory to the newly created Indian Territory. 

Relations between the state of Georgia and the Cherokee Nation were tense. The Cherokee had asked the Supreme Court in a case called Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, to recognize its treaty rights and stop Georgia from taking Cherokee land. In 1831, the Court held there was nothing it could do because the Cherokee were not a foreign nation.

The question came before the Court again a year later. But this time, the case was brought by White northern missionaries rather than the Cherokee. And this time, the Court sided with the White missionaries and proved willing to recognize the Cherokee Nation as a separate political identity. The 1832 case was called Worcester v. Georgia. Christian Missionaries sent by the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions, the first organized missionary society in the United States (look for them again when we talk about Hawaii), were sent South by their churches to Christianize Native Americans, including the Cherokee. The state of Georgia began forcing these White missionaries to swear allegiance to the state, and thus to support state slavery laws. When the missionaries refused, they were arrested. Elizur Butler was one such missionary. He was arrested by the Georgia militia and sentenced to two years of hard labor.[15] 

This time, the Supreme Court sided with the White missionaries and found Georgia’s effort to police missionaries on Cherokee land unconstitutional. As the Court explained, “the laws of Georgia [and other states] can have no force.”[16] While the Court did not explicitly take the side of the Cherokee, the result of Worcester v. Georgia was that the federal government could intervene to protect the Cherokee from state intrusions. The Court, perhaps somewhat inadvertently, had affirmed that Native nations had “sovereignty.”

However, the Supreme Court had no power to enforce its decision and make Georgia respect Cherokee sovereignty. Enforcement power lies with state and federal executives (like governors or presidents) and their respect for the rule of law and the separation of powers–ideas foundational to American democracy. Georgia’s governor vowed to defy the Court. And President Andrew Jackson did not force Georgia to comply. Worcester v. Georgia is historically important in two ways. First, because it officially recognized Native sovereignty. And second, because it provides an important historical example that the law is only as powerful as our collective respect and willingness to abide by judicial decisions.[17] 

Not all White Americans approved of removal. In December of 1839, reformer Catharine Beecher wrote a circular, “Addressed to the Benevolent Ladies of the United States.” In it, she exhorted women to appeal to the government to stop the removal policy and protect Indigenous communities. Appealing to women, she asked, “Have not then the females of this country have some duties devolving upon them to this helpless race?”[18] Beecher used biblical language from Exodus 22: 21-24 to support her claim that women had a responsibility to try to influence their government.

More than 1,400 women from Monson, Massachusetts, to Steubenville, Ohio signed petitions on behalf of the Native Americans. Women in Hallowell, Maine, asserted that they were “unwilling that the church, the school, and the domestic altar should be thrown down before the avaricious god of power.”[19] But American women could not vote, and their pleas fell on deaf ears.

Despite this opposition, it is important to remember that removal was popularly endorsed, supported by Congress, and spanned multiple political administrations and presidencies. While Jackson is often the focus in historical discussions of this period, his actions would not have been possible had the policy of removal not been so widely supported.

Jackson was intent on enforcing the Indian Removal Act. A few tribes negotiated treaties that promised that they would be well-treated, but they were nevertheless forcibly removed from their land. In the winter of 1831, with the US Army at their doorstep, the Choctaw became the first of many Native nations forced from their homeland on what would become known as the Trail of Tears. They marched 1,000 miles on foot, some in chains, without food or supplies. Along the way, they were subjected to brutal treatment, including the rape of many women.

Although some of the generals directly tasked with Indigenous removal advocated for more resources and time in an attempt to treat the people more humanely, Jackson pushed for haste and economic efficiency– directly resulting in the greater suffering for Indigenous people.

 

Trail of Tears 

In 1836, the Creeks were driven from their homes. An estimated 3,500 of the 15,000 Creeks died from diseases such as whooping cough, typhus, dysentery, cholera, as well as fatigue.

 

This map gives you a sense for the long route the tribes had to make from the Southeast to Indian Territory, present day Oklahoma (public domain).[20]

 

By 1838, only about 2,000 Cherokees had complied with removal orders, so President Martin Van Buren, who had been Jackson’s Vice President during his second term, ordered 7,000 soldiers to speed up the process, marching the Native families, the elderly and children included, at bayonet point.

Major Ridge, a Cherokee leader who had been negotiating with the US for decades, saw the situation as it was and tried to convince his tribe to leave. However, trying to make the argument to leave without sounding like a traitor to the Cherokee cause was undoubtedly a difficult line to walk. Ridge, who had supported “civilizing” efforts by the Cherokee, even educating his children at mission schools, had originally opposed land concessions. But by 1832, he advocated emigration, believing the alternative was the destruction of his people. In 1838, Ridge signed a conciliatory treaty with the US, a decision he described as his “death warrant” because the treaty did not have the support of the Cherokee community. Indeed, he was right. The treaty was supported by only 70 of the nearly 16,000 Cherokee tribal members and violated the Cherokee Constitution that prohibited land from being sold without the consent of the majority.[21] Ridge was considered a traitor, and his former partner in negotiations, John Ross, worked to overturn the treaty.

In May 1838, the US Army herded over 16,000 Cherokees into holding camps and began marching them west. Natives who fled were shot. Women in these camps, and along the trail, were sexually assaulted by US soldiers – a gendered strategy to humiliate not only the women, but their male family members, as well. Sexual assault served as a way of emasculating the men and reminding them of their weakness through their failure to protect. It is also the result of unequal power relations. So many Cherokee died that the Army postponed the rest of the march until the fall– forcing the Cherokee to march through the frigid winter months.

 

 

This image is based on a 1942 painting by Robert Lindneux called The Trail of Tears. Lindneux was careful to research the historical details about what the Cherokee wore and carried on their long, forced march.[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [22]

 

Major Ridge moved westward with the Cherokee on the Trail of Tears, but divisions within the Cherokee tribes were deep. Ridge, along with his son and others who had signed the emigration treaty, were executed by their own people. Under Cherokee law, they had sold land without the support of the majority, a crime punishable by death.

One Cherokee woman, Wahnenauhi, recalled her experience during the beginning of the Trail of Tears and forced removal of the Cherokee people. “They were gathered up and driven, at the point of the bayonet, into camp with the others. [T]hey were not allowed to take any of their household stuff, but were compelled to leave as they were, with only the clothes which they had on. One old, very old man asked the soldiers to allow him time to pray once more, with his family in the dear old home, before he left it forever. The answer was, with a brutal oath, ‘No! No time for prayers. Go!’ at the same time giving him a rude push toward the door. Indians were evicted, the Whites entered, taking full possession of everything left.”[23]

Lucy Ames, a missionary, described her husband’s experience with the Cherokee on the Trail of Tears. Years earlier, her husband, Elizur Butler, had been arrested and sentenced to two years of hard labor for violating Georgia’s restrictions on missionaries. Ames described the brutal trek in a letter to a friend: “When these companies arrive in their new country, the greatest part will be without shelters as they were in this [place], after they were prisoners; and it is to be feared many will be cut down by death, as has been the case with new emigrants in the country… Will not the people in whose power it is to redress Indian wrongs awake to their duty? Will they not think of the multitudes among the various tribes that have within a few years been swept into Eternity by the cupidity of the ‘White man’ who is in the enjoyment of wealth and freedom on the original soil of these oppressed Indians?”[24]

Eliza Whitmire was about five years old when she and her parents, who were enslaved to a Cherokee family, were forced to leave Georgia. She later described the process of removal: “The women and children were driven from their homes, sometimes with blows and close on the heels of the retreating Indians came greedy Whites to pillage the Indian's homes, drive off their cattle, horses, and pigs, and they even rifled the graves for any jewelry, or other ornaments that might have been buried with the dead… The aged, sick and young children rode in the wagons, which carried provisions and bedding, while others went on foot… all who lived to make this trip, or had parents who made it, will long remember it, as a bitter memory.”[25]

Rachel Dodge recalled the stories of her grandmother, Aggie Silk, from the Trail of Tears, providing a sense for the harsh conditions that men, women, and children faced on the trail. “Aggie Silk was my grandmother and she has told me of the many hardships of the trip to this country. Many had chills and fever from the exposure, change of country and they didn't have too much to eat. When they would get too sick to walk or ride, they were put in the wagons and taken along until they died. The Indian doctors couldn't find the herbs they were used to and didn't know the ones they did find, so they couldn't doctor them as they would have at home. Some rode in wagons, some rode horses and some had to walk. There was a large bunch when she came; she was sixteen years old. They were Cherokees and stopped close to Muldrow where they built log houses or cabins but they didn't like this country at first as everything was so strange.”[26]

Elizabeth Watts, the daughter of a woman who was born along the Trail of Tears, recounted her grandmother’s story of the removal in an oral history: “Even before they were loaded in wagons, many of them got sick and died… The trail was more than tears. It was death, sorrow, hunger, exposure, and humiliation to a civilized people as were the Cherokees.”[27]

Another oral history described: “Sin-e-cha…had left her home and with shattered happiness she carried a small bundle of her few belongings and reopening and retying her pitiful bundle she began a sad song… ‘I have no more land. I am driven away from home, driven up the red waters, let us all go, let us all die together and somewhere upon the banks we will be there.’”[28][7] [8] 

Josephine Usray Lattimer was interviewed by Amelia Harris. She said, “Even for all the well and strong, the journey was almost beyond human endurance. Many were weak and broken-hearted, and as night came there were new graves dug beside the way.”[29]

At least 4,000, but possibly 8,000, Cherokees died on the Trail of Tears. Those figures don’t include the thousands more Creek, Choctaw, Seminole, and other natives who perished in this forced removal.

 

Northwestern Removal

Similar tensions played out in the Northwestern Territory at the same time as the Trail of Tears. Note that the Northwest Territory refers to an area we now know as the Upper Midwest, but in a time before the US had reached the Pacific, this area was indeed both north and west. Again, treaties were mishandled, arguably fraudulent, resulting in war and the eventual forced removal of Native Americans. The brief and bloody Black Hawk War in 1832 opened new territory for White settlement. Millions of acres of land in present-day Illinois, Michigan, and Wisconsin were taken from the Sauk, Fox, and other nations.

In this region too, women played an important role. Sauk and Mesquaki women held positions of power in their communities. These communities thrived on sustainable systems of land use, cycling through hunting, gathering, farming, fishing, and sugar-making as the seasons dictated. Men and women were essential to this subsistence labor, much to the chagrin of European onlookers, who claimed these “laboring women” were slaves to their men. Men and women spent portions of the year apart, as men left to follow game, trap, and hunt. While the men were gone, women, children, and the elderly processed maple sugar for sustenance.

Mixed-race women (called Métis by French Canadians) in these communities often served as liaisons with the intruding White settlers because they spoke multiple languages. Seen as “public mothers,” they helped bridge cultural barriers and negotiate between groups. Metis women also resisted colonization in their own ways. Elizabeth Thérèse Fisher Baird, who spoke French, Odawa, and English, wrote a memoir describing her childhood on Mackinac Island (in what would become Michigan) with her mother, who ran a school for fur traders’ daughters, and the Ho-Chunk and Menominee tribes who lived nearby.[30] 

Others aligned themselves with resistance groups. When Black Hawk organized a rebellion against an unjust treaty, women were behind him. Women were some of his strongest allies because their contributions to the communal economy relied on their familiarity with the land. Violating a treaty they deemed unjust, Black Hawk and his followers crossed the river into Illinois to harvest crops from their fields. The settlers responded by requesting troops to reinforce them. Bloody skirmishes erupted, people were scalped and massacred. Two White teenage girls were kidnapped and ransomed back, but the Sauk were losing. Retreating quickly, they abandoned the slow and weary, leaving children and the elderly to be picked off by the US Army.

Like the Natives of the Southeast, the communities of the Northwest were also forced further west. By 1837, their lands, farms, and territory were being used by White families. ​

 

Migration to the West of the Muskogee

Another personal account of the migration of Indigenous people comes from Mary Hill, who in 1937 recalled her grandmother, Sallie Farney’s experience of forced migration from Alabama to the Western Continental U.S. Before the Trail of Tears, the Muskogee people were located in Alabama and, as Hill explained, believed “Alabama was to be the permanent home of the Muskogee tribe. But many different rumors of a removal to the far west was often heard.”[31]

Hill recounted how these rumors of removal suddenly became a reality to her grandmother and the Muskogee. Hill recalled her grandmother describing the day the Muskogee people were commanded to forcibly leave their homes: “Wagons stopped at our home and the men in charge commanded us to gather what few belongings could be crowded into the wagons. We were to be taken away and leave our homes never to return. This was just the beginning of much weeping and heartaches.”[32]

Hill explained how her grandmother described the way people were often “penned up,” put into closed quarters with other tribes, and separated from family and loved ones, before even beginning the dangerous forced migration west. Once they began moving west, conditions were dire:

 

Many fell by the wayside, too faint with hunger or too weak to keep up with the rest. The aged, feeble, and sick were left to perish by the wayside. A crude bed was quickly prepared for these sick and weary people. Only a bowl of water was left within reach, thus they were left to suffer and die alone. The little children piteously cried day after day from weariness, hunger, and illness. Many of the men, women, and even the children were forced to walk. They were once happy children - left without mother and father - crying could not bring consolation to those children. The sick and the births required attention, yet there was no time or no one was prepared. Death stalked at all hours, but there was no time for proper burying or ceremonies. My grandfather died on this trip.”[33]

 

Hill remembers her grandmother describing how Muscogee[34] women encouraged and sought to lift the spirit of the tribe as they moved west, “Some of the older women sang songs that meant, ‘We are going to our homes and land; there is One who is above and ever watches over us; He will care for us.’ This song was to encourage the ever downhearted Muskogees.”[35]

Hill’s retelling of her grandmother’s account of the horrors, sadness, and despair of forced removal is a vivid illustration of the subhuman treatment that was forced upon Indigenous people. Importantly, it also shows the bravery, perseverance, and resilience of many Muscogee women. Their continued strength, support, and sense of community helped the Muscogee people to survive the terror and horror of their forced removal and migration. Hill’s account of her grandmother’s story is one of many stories that show resilience in the face of tragedy and a commitment to preserve culture and community despite heartbreaking dislocation.


This print from Currier and Ives, a popular publisher, was printed sometime between 1856 and 1907, and is titled Scenery of the Upper Mississippi: An Indian Village (public domain).[36]


Aftermath

Traumatized and with few resources, women in these communities found the strength and resilience to rebuild. They built new homes, churches, and schools. John Ross, the Cherokee leader who had opposed removal, ensured the reluctant government paid the Cherokee for their lands in the east. Women raised their families and did the important work of enduring and surviving. They shared their stories and told the history of what happened to their people.

Elizur Butler and Lucy Ames continued to serve as missionaries with the Cherokee. He was a teacher at the Cherokee Female Seminary prior to his death in Arkansas in 1857. This work helped promote educational and economic opportunities, such as they were, for Cherokee women.

Not all missionary work was embraced, however. The long history of Euro-American and Christian ideology left bitter resentments. Sophia Sawyer, a female Christian missionary, apparently chased a local woman hoping to convince her to send her child into the missionary school. The Cherokee woman responded that she would “as soon see her child in hell as in the mission classroom.”[37]

 


Photographed sometime between 1870 and 1880, Helen Hunt Jackson had by this time become an activist on behalf of the Native American communities (public domain).[38] 

At the end of the century, Helen Hunt Jackson published an important book, A Century of Dishonor, that exposed the treatment of Indigenous people. She wrote, “There is no escape from the inexorable logic of facts. The history of the government's connections with the Indians is a shameful record of broken treaties and unfulfilled promises. The history of the border, White man’s connection with the Indians is a sickening record of murder, outrage, robbery, and wrongs committed by the former, as the rule, and occasional savage outbreaks and unspeakably barbarous deeds of retaliation by the latter, as the exception… The testimony of some of the highest military officers of the United States is on record to the effect that, in our Indian wars, almost without exception, the first aggressions have been made by the White man.”[39] She spoke the truth.

 

Conclusion

The federal government promised that the new lands in Oklahoma would remain untouched by Americans forever, but of course, the US continued expansion westward. In 1907, Oklahoma became a state, and Indian Territory was considered lost. Native women struggled alongside other American women in a quest for rights they had once held but lost through the intrusions of Euro-American ideals. Today, the Cherokee, Choctaw, Chickasaw, and Seminole holdings in Oklahoma together comprise only about 40% of total land.[40] 

Ironically, this “barren land” reserved for Native Americans so that the more fertile lands in the east could be cultivated for cash crops and the expansion of slavery held a secret. In 1859, the Ross family discovered oil. In a great twist of fate, Indigenous families who owned the headrights to the oil would become incredibly wealthy as the need for oil to fuel the Industrial Revolution took off. Headrights could not be bought or sold, only inherited– and since traditional communities were matrilineal, this meant that this wealth should have passed from mother to daughter for generations.

When the Osage of northern Oklahoma discovered vast reserves of oil, white fortune hunters came in search of this wealth. A 1921 federal law required that Osage tribal members prove they were competent to manage their money, and if not, be appointed a legal guardian to manage their oil wealth. Tragically, but perhaps unsurprisingly, the courts often found the Osage incompetent. It is estimated that these legal guardians stole at least $8 million dollars from their Osage wards. Others sought to marry women with headrights, using marriage law to gain control over Osage women’s wealth. So much wealth and greed led to a spate of deaths, many unsolved and unprosecuted.[41] 

Nevertheless, Indigenous women endured. At the end of the 20th century, many Cherokee women re-entered the public stage. In 1985, Wilma Mankiller became the principal chief of the Cherokee Nation in Oklahoma. In 2018, Deb Haaland, a member of the Laguna Pueblo tribe, was elected to the US House of Representatives, and in 2020 she was appointed by President Joe Biden to serve as the Secretary of the Interior, the first Native American to serve as a Cabinet secretary.

Similarly, among the Eastern Band of the Cherokee, Joyce Dugan led the tribe from 1995 to 1999. She is celebrated for taking a big, calculated risk to fund and open the tribe's first casino, which transformed the community by bringing much needed economic development. She also purchased back Kituwah, a 16,000 year old sacred Cherokee ancestral home site, integrating it into tribal land again; the site had been ransacked and destroyed by colonial settlers in the 1700s. She remains the tribe's only female chief.[42]

The success of these Cherokee women is a testament to their ability to embody the values exhibited by Cherokee women, as well as showing how the Cherokee nation is not a history of decline and loss of culture, but of perseverance, change, tragedy, and ultimate survival.

By the end of this era, so much remained in question. What would happen to the remaining native tribes west of the Mississippi? Would Native people ever be considered US Citizens? And if so, would they want to be?


Checking For Understanding

  1. What was the idea of Manifest Destiny, and how did it help justify westward expansion in the United States?

  2. How did the roles and rights of Cherokee women differ from those of many White American women during the early 1800s?

  3. Why did President Andrew Jackson support the removal of Native Americans from their homelands?

  4. What was the significance of the Indian Removal Act of 1830, and how did it affect Native communities?

  5. How did Native women help their families and communities survive during and after forced removal?

  6. What examples from the chapter show the resilience and perseverance of Native women despite displacement and loss?




 



[1] Katharine Bates, America the Beautiful, 1893, Library of Congress,

https://www.loc.gov/collections/patriotic-melodies/articles-and-essays/america-the-beautiful/.

[2] John Gast, American Progress, 1872, illustration, Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:American_Progress_(John_Gast_painting).jpg. A thoughtful discussion of using this image in the classroom is available from: Martha Sandweiss, “John Gast, American Progress, 1872,” Picturing United States History from the American Social History Project Center for Media and Learning, https://picturinghistory.gc.cuny.edu/john-gast-american-progress-1872/.

.

[3] Unknown Artist, Battle Horseshoe Bend 1814, 1847, illustration, Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Battle_Horseshoe_Bend_1814.jpg.

[4] Brian Hicks, “The Cherokees vs. Andrew Jackson,” Smithsonian Magazine, March, 2011, The Cherokees vs. Andrew Jackson.

[5] “Slavery in the Cherokee Nation: Selling Captured Warriors, Buying African Slaves, Rabun County Historical Society, Slavery in the Cherokee Nation: Selling Captured Warriors, Buying African Slaves.

[6] ICT Staff Editors, “The Power of Cherokee Women: A Tragic Story of European Conquest and Resulting Spiritual Confusion,” Indian Country Today, September, 2018, https://ictnews,.org/archive/the-power-of-cherokee-women.

[7] Ibid.

[8] ICT Staff Editors, “The Power of Cherokee Women: A Tragic Story of European Conquest and Resulting Spiritual Confusion.”

[9]As quoted in  ICT Staff Editors, “The Power of Cherokee Women: A Tragic Story of European Conquest and Resulting Spiritual Confusion.”

[10] Brian Hicks, “The Cherokees v. Andrew Jackson: John Ross and Major Ridge Tried Diplomatic Strategies to Maintain Autonomy, but the New President Had Other Plans.”

[11] Ralph Eleaser and Whiteside Earl, Portrait of Rachel Jackson,  circa 1823-1828, painting, Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rachel_Donelson_Jackson_by_Ralph_E._W._Earl.jpg.

[12] As quoted in Lorraine Boissoneault, “Rachel Jackson, the Scandalous Divorcee Who Almost Became First Lady,” Smithsonian Magazine 15 June 15, 2017 

[13] “Rachel Jackson,” Andrew Jackson’s Hermitage, https://thehermitage.com/rachel-jackson; “Rachel Jackson,” American Battlefield Trust, https://www.battlefields.org/learn/biographies/rachel-jackson 

[14]Catherine Allgor, “Female Trouble: Andrew Jackson versus the Ladies of Washington,” History Now, Issue 22 (Winter 2009)

https://www.gilderlehrman.org/history-resources/essays/female-trouble-andrew-jackson-versus-ladies-washington

[15] Georgia History Editors, “Dr. Elizur Butler: Missionary to the Cherokees,” Georgia History. https://georgiahistory.com/ghmi_marker_updated/dr-elizur-esther-butler-missionaries-to-the-cherokees/.

[16] Worcester v. Georgia 31 U.S. 515 (1832).

[17] The refusal of President Jackson to enforce the Supreme Court’s decision in Worcester v Georiga (1832) is in stark contrast to President Eisenhower’s decision to enforce the 1955 Brown v. Board of Education decision by deploying federal troops.

[18] Catharine Beecher, "Circular: Addressed to Benevolent Ladies of the United States" (Boston: Crocker & Brewster, 1829), reprinted in Teaching American History, ed. Sarah A. Morgan Smith, accessed August 21, 2026, https://teachingamericanhistory.org/document/circular-addressed-to-benevolent-ladies-of-the-united-states/.

[19] Erin Blakemore, "The Women Who Tried to Prevent the Trail of Tears," JSTOR Daily, 10 Dec. 2018, https://daily.jstor.org/the-women-who-tried-to-prevent-the-trail-of-tears/.

[20] Trail of Tears: depicting the route taken to relocated Native Americans from the Southeastern United States between 1836 and 1839, 2007, map, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Trails_of_Tears_en.png with background map courtesy of Demis www.demis.nl present-day.

[21]History Editors, “Trial of Tears,” History, March 24, 2023

[22] Robert O. Lindneux, The Trail of Tears, 1942, illustration, National Trail of Tears Association, https://nationaltota.com/website-banner-mural/.

[23] John G. Burnett, "The Cherokee Removal Through the Eyes of a Private Soldier," Digital History, University of Houston, accessed August 20, 2026, https://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/disp_textbook_print.cfm?smtid=3&psid=1147.

[24] “‘Swept into Eternity’ Impact of Cherokee Removal and Washington’s Apathy,” Fort Smith National Historic Site, National Park Service https://www.nps.gov/fosm/learn/historyculture/impact-of-cherokee-removal.htm 

[25] Eliza Whitmire, interview, 1938 American Native Press Archives and Sequoyah Research Center, https://ualrexhibits.org/tribalwriters/artifacts/Family-Stories-Trail-of-Tears.html#Whitmire 

[26] Rachel Dodge, interview by Grace Kelley, 1937, American Native Press Archives and Sequoyah Research Center, https://ualrexhibits.org/tribalwriters/artifacts/Family-Stories-Trail-of-Tears.html#Watts 

[27]Elizabeth Watts, interview by L.D. Wilson, 27 April 1937, “The Removal as told to Mrs. Watts by her Grandparents, American Native Press Archives and Sequoyah Research Center, https://ualrexhibits.org/tribalwriters/artifacts/Family-Stories-Trail-of-Tears.html#Watts 

[28] .

[29] Josephine Usray Lattimer, interview by Amelia Harris, October 13, 1937, American Native Press Archives and Sequoyah Research Center, https://ualrexhibits.org/tribalwriters/artifacts/Family-Stories-Trail-of-Tears.html#Lattimer 

[30]  Wisconsin Women Making History, "Elizabeth Baird," accessed August 20, 2026, https://womeninwisconsin.org/profile/elizabeth-baird/.

[31] Mary Hill, interview by Billie Byrd, "The Migration to the West of the Muskogee," Indian-Pioneer History (Oklahoma Historical Society), April 19, 1937,

https://www.nps.gov/common/uploads/teachers/lessonplans/Real%20Stories%20from%20Interviews.pdf.

[32] Mary Hill, interview by Billie Byrd, "The Migration to the West of the Muskogee," Indian-Pioneer History (Oklahoma Historical Society), April 19, 1937,

https://www.nps.gov/common/uploads/teachers/lessonplans/Real%20Stories%20from%20Interviews.pdf.

[33] Ibid.

[34] Muscogee is the preferred spelling of the Muscogee community. Historical sources use an older spelling, Muskogee.

[35] Ibid.

[36] Scenery of the Upper Mississippi: an Indian Village, Between 1856 and 1907, illustration, Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Scenery_of_the_upper_Mississippi-_an_Indian_village_LCCN2001705805.jpg.

[37]Lucy Butler, "Letter to Drusilla Burnap," January 2, 1839, in "'Swept Into Eternity': Impact of Cherokee Removal and Washington's Apathy," National Park Service, https://www.nps.gov/fosm/learn/historyculture/impact-of-cherokee-removal.htm.

[38] C. C. Pierce, Helen Hunt Jackson, Before 1885, photograph, Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Helen_Hunt_Jackson_oac.jpg.

[39] Helen Hunt Jackson, A Century of Dishonor: A Sketch of the United States Government’s Dealings with Some of the Indian Tribes (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1881), 337.

[40]Matthew LM Fletcher, “New Media Writers: Please Stop Saying “Half” of Oklahoma is "Indian Lands” or “Indian Territory” – It’s Not (Yet). Turtle Talk: Leading Blog on Legal Issues in Indian Country. 5 Aug 2020. https://turtletalk.blog/2020/08/05/news-media-writers-please-stop-saying-half-of-oklahoma-is-indian-lands-or-indian-territory-its-not-yet/

[41] Vincent Schilling, “How Marriage and Murder Were Used to Steal Osage Oil Riches,” History

https://www.history.com/articles/osage-murders-reign-terror-husbands-guardians; Dennis McAuliffe, The Deaths of Sybil Bolton: Oil, Greed and Murder on the Osage Reservation.

[42] Brooklyn Brown and Julia Duvall, “WCU to honor Joyce Dugan for decades of service to education, EBCI, WNC,” April 23, 2026, https://www.wcu.edu/stories/posts/wcu-to-honor-joyce-dugan-for-decades-of-service-to-education-ebci-wnc.aspx.



Weitermachen

I'm a paragraph. Click here to add your own text and edit me. It's easy.

Im nächsten Kapitel erfahren Sie mehr über Frauengeschichte.

MONATLICHE GÄSTE
Jeff Eckert, Barbara Tischler, Brooke Sullivan, Christian Bourdo, Kent Heckel, Jenna Koloski, Nancy Heckel, Megan Torrey-Payne, Leah Tanger, Mark Bryer, Nicole Woulfe, Alicia Gutierrez-Romine, Katya Miller, Michelle Stonis, Jessica Freire, Laura Holiday, Jacqui Nelson, Annabelle Blevins Pifer, Dawn Cyr, Megan Gary, Melissa Adams, Victoria Plutshack, Rachel Lee, Perez, Kate Kemp, Bridget Erlandson, Leah Spellerberg, Rebecca Sanborn Marshall, Ashley Satterfield, Milly Neff, Alexandra Plutshack, Martha Wheelock, Gwen Duralek, Maureen Barthen, Pamela Scully, Elizabeth Blanchard und Christina Luzzi.

HAUPTSPENDER
Pioniere: Deb Coffin, Annalee Davis Thorndike Foundation, Rhode Island Community Foundation
Symbol: Jean German, Dr. Barbara und Dr. Steve Tischler, Dr. Leah Redmond Chang

Bleiben Sie mit unserem Newsletter auf dem Laufenden.

© 2025 von

Das Projekt zur Aufarbeitung der Frauengeschichte.

Alle Rechte vorbehalten.

bottom of page